Menu Top
Business Studies NCERT Notes, Solutions and Extra Q & A (Class 11th & 12th)
11th 12th

Class 12th Chapters
1. Nature And Significance Of Management 2. Principles Of Management 3. Business Environment
4. Planning 5. Organising 6. Staffing
7. Directing 8. Controlling 9. Financial Management
10. Financial Markets 11. Marketing 12. Consumer Protection

Content On This Page
Meaning of Business Finance Financial Management Objectives of Financial Management
Financial Decisions Financial Planning Capital Structure
Fixed and Working Capital
NCERT Questions Solution



Chapter 9 Financial Management Notes, Solutions and Extra Q & A



Financial Management is concerned with the optimal procurement (raising funds) and the effective usage (investing funds) of finance. Its primary objective is the maximisation of shareholders’ wealth, which is achieved by increasing the market price of the company's equity shares. This requires a careful balance of risk and return. The entire scope of financial management can be understood through three broad and interrelated decisions.

The first is the Investment Decision (or Capital Budgeting), which relates to the allocation of funds to profitable long-term assets. The second is the Financing Decision, which involves determining the optimal mix of debt and equity in the capital structure, a concept known as 'Trading on Equity' is also a part of this. The third is the Dividend Decision, which is about deciding how much of the profit should be distributed to shareholders versus how much should be retained in the business. The chapter also explores the concepts of financial planning and the factors influencing the requirements for both fixed capital and working capital.

Meaning of Business Finance

Business finance refers to the money required for carrying out all business activities. It is the lifeblood of any enterprise. Almost all business activities, from the initial establishment of a business to its day-to-day operations, and its long-term growth through expansion and modernisation, require some form of finance. Finance is needed to establish a business, to run it, to modernise it, and to diversify it.

This requirement for funds is primarily for acquiring a variety of assets, which may be:

Furthermore, finance is central to running the day-to-day operations of a business. This includes activities like buying raw materials, paying utility bills, paying salaries and wages to employees, and managing the cash flow from collecting money from customers. The availability of adequate finance at every stage of a business's life is, thus, a crucial and indispensable factor for its survival and growth.



Financial Management

All finance comes at some cost and carries some degree of risk. Therefore, it is imperative that these funds be carefully and efficiently managed. Financial Management is concerned with the optimal procurement as well as the effective usage of finance. It involves applying general management principles to the financial resources of an enterprise.

The two key aspects of Financial Management are:

1. Optimal Procurement of Funds: This involves identifying the different available sources of finance and comparing them in terms of their costs and associated risks. The aim is to procure the required funds at the lowest possible cost while keeping the financial risk under control. As seen in the case of Tata Steel's acquisition of Corus, the company had to decide on a mix of sources, including debt, equity from its parent company Tata Sons, and its own internal funds.

2. Effective Usage of Funds: This involves investing the procured funds in a manner that the returns generated from the investment exceed the cost at which the procurement has taken place. This ensures that the firm is creating value and not just covering its costs.

Financial Management also aims at ensuring the availability of enough funds whenever required for operations or investment, while also avoiding idle finance, which unnecessarily adds to the cost without generating any return. The long-term future of a business depends a great deal on the quality of its financial management.


Importance of Financial Management

The role of financial management is of paramount importance as it has a direct bearing on the financial health and overall success of a business. The financial statements of a firm, such as the Balance Sheet and the Profit and Loss Account, are a reflection of its financial position. Almost all items in these statements are affected directly or indirectly by some financial management decisions. Key aspects affected by financial management include:

Thus, the overall financial health and performance of a business are determined by the quality of its financial management. Good financial management aims at the mobilisation of financial resources at a lower cost and the deployment of these resources in the most lucrative and productive activities.



Objectives of Financial Management

The primary and overriding objective of financial management is to maximise shareholders’ wealth. This is often referred to as the wealth-maximisation concept. In practical terms, this means maximising the market value of the company's equity shares. This objective automatically takes care of all other objectives, such as profit maximisation and social welfare, as a company cannot create wealth for its shareholders in the long run without being profitable and socially responsible.

The market price of a company’s shares is directly linked to the three basic financial decisions: the investment decision, the financing decision, and the dividend decision. The company's funds ultimately belong to the shareholders, and the manner in which these funds are invested and the return earned by them determines the market value and price of their shares. The market price of an equity share increases if the benefit derived from a financial decision exceeds the cost involved. All financial decisions must, therefore, aim at ensuring that each decision is efficient and adds some value to the firm. Such value additions tend to increase the market price of the shares.

Therefore, when a decision is taken about investing in a new machine, the aim of financial management is to ensure that the benefits from the investment (in the form of future cash flows) exceed the cost of the investment, so that some value addition takes place. Similarly, when finance is procured, the aim is to reduce the cost as much as possible so that the value addition is even higher. In all financial decisions, the ultimate objective that guides the decision-maker is that some value addition should take place, which will ultimately lead to an increase in the price of the equity share and, thus, the wealth of the shareholders.



Financial Decisions

Financial management is concerned with the solution of three major issues relating to the financial operations of a firm. These correspond to three broad and interrelated decisions that every financial manager has to take: the investment decision, the financing decision, and the dividend decision.

A central box labelled 'Financial Decisions' is shown, with three arrows pointing to three other boxes. The first box is labelled 'Investment Decision (Capital Budgeting & Working Capital)', the second is 'Financing Decision (Capital Structure)', and the third is 'Dividend Decision (Profit Distribution)'.

1. Investment Decision

A firm’s resources are scarce and have alternative uses. Therefore, a firm has to choose where to invest these resources to earn the highest possible return for its investors. The investment decision relates to how the firm’s funds are invested in different assets. Investment decisions can be long-term or short-term.

Factors affecting Capital Budgeting Decisions:

  1. Cash flows of the project: A project involves a series of cash outflows (investment) and cash inflows (returns) over its life. These cash flows should be carefully estimated and analysed.

  2. The rate of return: The expected returns from each proposal and the assessment of the risk involved are the most important criteria. A project is selected only if its rate of return is higher than a certain minimum acceptable rate.

  3. The investment criteria involved: There are various scientific capital budgeting techniques (like Net Present Value, Internal Rate of Return) that are used to evaluate and compare investment proposals based on calculations involving the amount of investment, interest rate, cash flows, and rate of return.


2. Financing Decision

This decision is about the quantum of finance to be raised from various long-term sources. The main sources of funds for a firm are shareholders’ funds (equity) and borrowed funds (debt). A firm has to decide the proportion of funds to be raised from these sources. This decision determines the firm's capital structure, its overall cost of capital, and its financial risk.

Factors affecting Financing Decisions:

  1. Cost: The cost of raising funds from different sources varies. A prudent financial manager would normally opt for the source that is the cheapest.

  2. Risk: The risk associated with each source is different. Debt is more risky for the firm as the payment of interest and the repayment of the principal are obligatory, regardless of profits.

  3. Floatation Costs: These are the costs involved in raising funds (e.g., brokerage and underwriting fees for a public issue). Higher floatation costs make a source less attractive.

  4. Cash Flow Position: A company with a strong and stable cash flow position is better able to meet its fixed payment obligations and can, therefore, opt for more debt financing.

  5. Fixed Operating Costs: If a business has high fixed operating costs (like rent and salaries), it should reduce its fixed financing costs by opting for lower debt to manage its overall risk.

  6. Control Considerations: Issuing more equity shares can lead to a dilution of the existing shareholders' control over the business, whereas debt financing does not have this implication.

  7. State of Capital Market: The health and condition of the capital market (whether it is bullish or bearish) affects the choice between debt and equity. It is easier to raise equity in a booming market.


3. Dividend Decision

This decision relates to the distribution of the profits earned by the company. The financial manager has to decide how much of the profit earned by the company (after paying tax) is to be distributed to the shareholders as a dividend and how much of it should be retained in the business for future investment needs (retained earnings). While dividends constitute the current income for shareholders, their re-investment as retained earnings increases the firm’s future earning capacity and the value of its shares. The decision regarding dividends should, therefore, be taken keeping in view the overall objective of maximising shareholders’ wealth.

Factors affecting Dividend Decisions:

  1. Amount of Earnings: Dividends are paid out of a company's current and past earnings, so the level of earnings is a major determinant of the dividend decision.

  2. Stability of Earnings: A company with stable and consistent earnings is in a better position to declare higher and more regular dividends.

  3. Stability of Dividends: Companies generally follow a policy of maintaining a stable dividend per share, as investors value consistency.

  4. Growth Opportunities: Companies that have good growth and investment opportunities tend to retain a larger portion of their earnings to finance these investments.

  5. Cash Flow Position: The payment of dividends involves an outflow of cash. Therefore, a company must have sufficient cash available to be able to pay the declared dividends.

  6. Shareholders’ Preference: The management must keep in mind the preferences of the shareholders. If shareholders generally desire a regular income, the company is likely to declare a dividend.

  7. Taxation Policy: The tax treatment of dividends in the hands of the shareholders and the dividend distribution tax levied on companies can affect the dividend decision.

  8. Stock Market Reaction: An increase in dividend is generally viewed as good news by investors, and stock prices tend to react positively to it. The management considers this potential market reaction.

  9. Access to Capital Market: Large and reputed companies that have easy access to the capital market for raising funds may depend less on retained earnings and can, therefore, afford to pay higher dividends.

  10. Legal and Contractual Constraints: The provisions of the Companies Act and the terms of any loan agreements may place certain restrictions on the payment of dividends.



Financial Planning

Financial planning is a crucial process that is concerned with anticipating the future financial needs of an organisation. It is essentially the preparation of a financial blueprint of an organisation’s future operations. The objective of financial planning is to ensure that enough funds are available at the right time for various purposes, from long-term investments to day-to-day expenses.

It is important to understand that financial planning is not a substitute for financial management. While financial management aims at choosing the best investment and financing alternatives by focusing on their costs and benefits, financial planning aims at ensuring smooth operations by focusing on fund requirements and their availability in light of the financial decisions that have been made.

Financial planning typically begins with the preparation of a sales forecast. Based on this, financial statements are prepared to estimate the requirement of funds for investment in fixed and working capital. The process also forecasts shortages and surpluses so that necessary actions can be taken in advance.


Objectives of Financial Planning

Financial planning strives to achieve the following twin objectives, which are two sides of the same coin:

  1. To ensure the availability of funds whenever required: This is the primary objective. It includes a proper estimation of the funds required for different purposes (long-term assets, day-to-day expenses) and the exact time at which these funds are to be made available. Financial planning also tries to specify the possible sources from which these funds can be raised.

  2. To see that the firm does not raise resources unnecessarily: Excess funding is almost as bad as inadequate funding. If a firm has surplus funds, it will remain idle and will unnecessarily add to the cost without generating any return. Good financial planning ensures that surplus money is put to the best possible use.

Thus, a proper matching of fund requirements and their availability is sought to be achieved by financial planning.


Importance of Financial Planning

Financial planning is an important part of the overall planning of any business enterprise. Its importance can be explained by the following points:



Capital Structure

One of the most important decisions under financial management relates to the financing pattern of the firm, which is the proportion of the use of different sources in raising the required funds. Capital structure refers to the mix between owners' funds (equity) and borrowed funds (debt) used to finance the assets of a company.

Owners' funds consist of equity share capital, preference share capital, and reserves and surpluses (retained earnings). Borrowed funds can be in the form of loans, debentures, and public deposits. Capital structure can be expressed as a debt-equity ratio, i.e., $ \frac{Debt}{Equity} $, or as the proportion of debt out of the total capital, i.e., $ \frac{Debt}{Debt+Equity} $.

Debt and equity differ significantly in their cost and riskiness. Debt is generally cheaper than equity because lenders' risk is lower than that of equity shareholders (as lenders get an assured return and repayment). Additionally, the interest paid on debt is a tax-deductible expense. However, debt is more risky for a business because the payment of interest and the return of principal are obligatory. Any default in these commitments can force the business into liquidation. This risk is known as financial risk. Equity, on the other hand, is considered riskless for the business as there is no legal compulsion to pay dividends or repay the capital.

A capital structure is said to be optimal when the proportion of debt and equity is such that it results in an increase in the value of the equity share, thereby maximising the wealth of the shareholders. The proportion of debt in the overall capital is also called financial leverage.


Trading on Equity

Trading on Equity is a financial practice that refers to the increase in the profit earned by the equity shareholders due to the presence of fixed financial charges like interest. The concept works on the principle that if a company can earn a higher rate of return on its investments than the interest rate it pays on its borrowed funds, the surplus will go to the equity shareholders, thus increasing their Earning Per Share (EPS).

While trading on equity can enhance the EPS, a reckless use of it is not recommended as it also significantly increases the financial risk of the company.

Example 1 (Favourable Leverage). A company with total funds of ₹ 30 Lakh and an EBIT (Earnings Before Interest and Tax) of ₹ 4 Lakh has a Return on Investment (RoI) of 13.33% ($ \frac{4,00,000}{30,00,000} \times 100 $). If this company borrows debt at an interest rate of 10%, its EPS will increase as it introduces more debt into its capital structure. This is because the return it is earning on the funds (13.33%) is higher than the cost it is paying for the borrowed funds (10%).

Example 2 (Unfavourable Leverage). If the same company has an EBIT of only ₹ 2 Lakh, its RoI is only 6.67% ($ \frac{2,00,000}{30,00,000} \times 100 $). In this case, if it borrows debt at 10%, its EPS will fall with the increased use of debt. This is because the cost of the borrowed funds (10%) is higher than the return the company is earning on those funds (6.67%).


Factors Affecting the Choice of Capital Structure

The choice of an appropriate capital structure that balances risk and return is a complex decision that depends on various factors. The key factors are:

  1. Cash Flow Position: A company must have a sufficiently large and stable cash flow to be able to meet its fixed payment obligations associated with debt (interest and principal repayment).

  2. Interest Coverage Ratio (ICR): This ratio, calculated as $ \frac{EBIT}{Interest} $, indicates the number of times the company's earnings before interest and taxes can cover its interest obligation. A higher ratio indicates a lower risk of default and a greater capacity to borrow.

  3. Debt Service Coverage Ratio (DSCR): This ratio is a more comprehensive measure of a company's ability to service its debt as it considers both interest and principal repayment obligations.

  4. Return on Investment (RoI): If the RoI of the company is higher than the cost of debt, the company can effectively use trading on equity to increase its EPS.

  5. Cost of Debt and Equity: A firm’s ability to borrow at a lower rate of interest increases its capacity to employ higher debt. The cost of equity also changes with the level of debt.

  6. Tax Rate: Since the interest paid on debt is a tax-deductible expense, a higher corporate tax rate makes debt a relatively cheaper source of finance.

  7. Floatation Costs: These are the costs involved in raising funds (e.g., brokerage and underwriting fees for a public issue). Raising funds through loans may involve lower floatation costs than a public issue of shares or debentures.

  8. Risk Consideration: The total risk of a business depends on both its business risk (which is related to its fixed operating costs) and its financial risk (which is related to its fixed financial charges).

  9. Flexibility: A firm should not use its debt potential to the full in normal times. It should maintain some borrowing power (flexibility) to be able to take care of unforeseen circumstances.

  10. Control: Debt financing does not dilute the control of the existing equity shareholders over the company, whereas issuing new equity shares to the public does.

  11. Regulatory Framework: Every company operates within a regulatory framework provided by the law (e.g., Companies Act, SEBI guidelines), which can influence the choice of financing.

  12. Stock Market Conditions: The condition of the stock market (whether it is bullish or bearish) affects the ease and cost of raising funds through equity.

  13. Capital Structure of Other Companies: The debt-equity ratios of other companies in the same industry can serve as a useful guideline, but they should not be followed blindly.



Fixed and Working Capital

Every company needs funds to finance its assets and activities. An investment is required in two types of assets: fixed assets and current assets.


Management of Fixed Capital

Fixed capital refers to the investment that a company makes in its long-term assets. The management of fixed capital involves the allocation of the firm’s capital to different projects or assets that have long-term implications for the business. These decisions are known as investment decisions or capital budgeting decisions, and they are crucial as they affect the growth, profitability, and risk of the business in the long run. These decisions are of great importance for the following reasons:

Factors affecting the Requirement of Fixed Capital:

  1. Nature of Business: A manufacturing concern requires more fixed capital than a trading concern because it needs to invest in plant and machinery.

  2. Scale of Operations: A larger organisation operating at a higher scale requires a higher investment in fixed assets than a smaller one.

  3. Choice of Technique: A capital-intensive organisation (that uses more machinery) requires more fixed capital than a labour-intensive one.

  4. Technology Upgradation: In industries where assets become obsolete sooner due to rapid technological changes, a higher investment in fixed assets is required for frequent replacements.

  5. Growth Prospects: A company with higher growth prospects generally requires a higher investment in fixed assets to build capacity in anticipation of higher demand.

  6. Diversification: When a firm chooses to diversify its operations by entering new product lines, its fixed capital requirements increase.

  7. Financing Alternatives: The availability of financing alternatives like leasing facilities can reduce the need to purchase assets outright, thus lowering the immediate fixed capital requirement.

  8. Level of Collaboration: If business organisations can share each other’s facilities (like a bank sharing another bank's ATM), it can reduce the level of investment in fixed assets for each organisation.


Working Capital

Apart from the investment in fixed assets, every business needs to invest in current assets to facilitate its smooth day-to-day operations. Working capital refers to the firm's investment in its current assets. While current assets are usually more liquid, they contribute less to the profits of the business than fixed assets. A key challenge is to strike a balance between liquidity and profitability.

Net working capital is a key metric in working capital management. It is defined as the excess of current assets over current liabilities (NWC = CA – CL). It represents the portion of current assets that is financed through long-term sources of funds.

Factors affecting the Working Capital Requirements:

  1. Nature of Business: A trading organisation or a service industry usually needs a smaller amount of working capital compared to a manufacturing organisation.

  2. Scale of Operations: Organisations that operate on a higher scale of operation generally require a larger amount of working capital to maintain higher levels of inventory and debtors.

  3. Business Cycle: In the case of a boom (upward phase of the business cycle), the sales and production are likely to be larger, and therefore, a larger amount of working capital is required. The opposite is true during a depression.

  4. Seasonal Factors: In the peak season for a business, a larger amount of working capital is required due to a higher level of activity. In the lean season, the requirement is lower.

  5. Production Cycle: The production cycle is the time span between the receipt of raw material and its conversion into finished goods. A business with a longer production cycle requires more working capital.

  6. Credit Allowed: A company that follows a liberal credit policy (allowing customers more time to pay) will have a higher amount of debtors, which increases its working capital requirement.

  7. Credit Availed: Just as a firm allows credit to its customers, it may also get credit from its suppliers. The more credit a firm avails on its purchases, the lower is its working capital requirement.

  8. Operating Efficiency: Firms that can manage their operations with a higher degree of efficiency (e.g., by maintaining a higher inventory turnover ratio or a better debtors turnover ratio) require a lower level of working capital.

  9. Availability of Raw Material: If raw materials are not freely and continuously available, a company may need to maintain higher stock levels, which increases its working capital.

  10. Growth Prospects: If the growth potential of a concern is perceived to be higher, it will require a larger amount of working capital to be able to meet the higher production and sales targets.

  11. Level of Competition: A higher level of competition may necessitate maintaining larger stocks of finished goods to meet urgent orders from customers. It may also force the firm to extend liberal credit terms.

  12. Inflation: With rising prices, larger amounts of funds are required even to maintain a constant volume of production and sales. Therefore, the working capital requirement of a business becomes higher with a higher rate of inflation.



NCERT Questions Solution



Very Short Answer Type

Question 1. What is meant by capital structure?

Answer:

Capital structure refers to the mix or proportion of long-term sources of funds, specifically debt (borrowed funds) and equity (owner's funds), used by a firm to finance its assets. It is expressed as the debt-equity ratio.

Question 2. Sate the two objectives of financial planning.

Answer:

The two primary objectives of financial planning are:


1. To ensure availability of funds whenever required: This includes estimating the funds required, the time at which they will be required, and the sources from which they will be raised.


2. To see that the firm does not raise resources unnecessarily: This is to avoid the problem of surplus funds, which increases costs and encourages wasteful expenditure.

Question 3. Name the concept of financial management which increases the return to equity shareholders due to the presence of fixed financial charges.

Answer:

The concept is called Trading on Equity or Financial Leverage.

Question 4. Amrit is running a ‘transport service’ and earning good returns by providing this service to industries. Giving reason, state whether the working capital requirement of the firm will be ‘less’ or ‘more’.

Answer:

The working capital requirement of the firm will be less.


Reason: A transport service is a service-based industry. Such firms do not need to maintain a large inventory of raw materials or finished goods. Also, their sales are usually in cash or have a very short credit period, leading to a faster cash conversion cycle.

Question 5. Ramnath is into the business of assembling and selling of televisions. Recently he has adopted a new policy of purchasing the components on three months credit and selling the complete product in cash. Will it affect the requirement of working capital? Give reason in support of your answer.

Answer:

Yes, this policy will reduce the requirement of working capital.


Reason: Ramnath is receiving a long credit period from his suppliers (3 months) but is selling his product for immediate cash. This means his cash conversion cycle will be negative. He will receive cash from his customers before he has to pay his suppliers. This liberal credit from suppliers will significantly reduce the amount of cash he needs to tie up in his operations.

Short Answer Type

Question 1. What is financial risk? Why does it arise?

Answer:

Financial risk refers to the risk that a firm may not be able to cover its fixed financial costs, such as interest on loans, preference dividends, and lease payments. It is the risk of the company's earnings per share (EPS) becoming more volatile due to the use of debt.


Financial risk arises when a company includes debt or other fixed-charge securities (like preference shares) in its capital structure. The company is legally obligated to pay interest on debt regardless of whether it earns a profit or not. If the company's earnings before interest and tax (EBIT) fall, it may not have enough profit to pay the interest, which could lead to insolvency. The higher the proportion of debt, the higher the financial risk.

Question 2. Define current assets? Give four examples of such assets.

Answer:

Current assets are those assets of a business which are expected to be converted into cash or consumed in the production of goods or rendering of services in the normal course of business, typically within one year or one operating cycle.


Four examples of current assets are:

  1. Cash in hand and cash at bank
  2. Inventories (including raw materials, work-in-progress, and finished goods)
  3. Bills Receivable (or Accounts Receivable)
  4. Prepaid Expenses

Question 3. What are the main objectives of financial management? Briefly explain.

Answer:

The primary objective of financial management is to maximize the wealth of the shareholders. This is known as the Wealth Maximisation objective. The market price of a company's shares is a direct indicator of shareholder wealth. Therefore, the main goal is to maximize the market value of the company's equity shares.


This primary objective is achieved by focusing on other supporting objectives:

1. Profit Maximisation: While not the sole objective, earning sufficient profit is essential for covering costs and providing a return to investors. It is a necessary condition for wealth maximisation.

2. Procurement of Sufficient Funds: To ensure that the company has adequate funds from the right sources at a reasonable cost to meet its operational and investment needs.

3. Efficient Utilisation of Funds: To ensure that the procured funds are invested in the most productive and profitable assets to generate maximum returns.

4. Maintaining Liquidity and Solvency: To ensure that the company has enough cash to meet its short-term liabilities (liquidity) and is able to meet its long-term obligations (solvency).

Question 4. Financial management is based on three broad financial decisions. What are these?

Answer:

Financial management is based on three broad and interrelated financial decisions. These are:


1. Investment Decision (Capital Budgeting): This decision relates to the careful selection of assets in which the firm's funds will be invested. It involves deciding how much to invest in long-term fixed assets (capital budgeting) and how much to invest in short-term current assets (working capital management).


2. Financing Decision: This decision is concerned with determining the optimal mix of various sources of long-term funds, primarily the proportion of debt and equity in the capital structure. It aims to find a balance that minimizes the cost of capital and maximizes shareholder wealth.


3. Dividend Decision: This decision relates to the appropriation of the company's profits. The finance manager has to decide how much of the profit earned should be distributed to the shareholders as dividends and how much should be retained in the business (retained earnings) for future investment needs.

Question 5. Sunrises Ltd. dealing in readymade garments, is planning to expand its business operations in order to cater to international market. For this purpose the company needs additional `80,00,000 for replacing machines with modern machinery of higher production capacity. The company wishes to raise the required funds by issuing debentures. The debt can be issued at an estimated cost of 10%. The EBIT for the previous year of the company was `8,00,000 and total capital investment was `1,00,00,000. Suggest whether issue of debenture would be considered a rational decision by the company. Give reason to justify your answer.

Answer:

To determine if issuing debentures is a rational decision, we need to compare the company's Return on Investment (ROI) with the cost of debt. This is the concept of Trading on Equity.


Calculations:

1. Cost of Debt: The estimated cost of debt is given as 10%.

2. Return on Investment (ROI): $ \text{ROI} = \frac{\text{EBIT}}{\text{Total Capital Investment}} \times 100 $ $ \text{ROI} = \frac{\textsf{₹ } 8,00,000}{\textsf{₹ } 1,00,00,000} \times 100 = 8\% $


Suggestion and Justification:

No, issuing debentures would not be a rational decision for the company at this point.

Reason: The company's Return on Investment (ROI) is 8%, while the cost of the proposed debt is 10%. Since the ROI (8%) is less than the Cost of Debt (10%), the company will have an unfavourable financial leverage. Using debt will decrease the Earnings Per Share (EPS) for the equity shareholders, as the company will be paying more in interest than it is earning on the borrowed funds. Therefore, the decision would be irrational.

Question 6. How does working capital affect both the liquidity as well as profitability of a business?

Answer:

Working capital management involves a trade-off between liquidity and profitability. The amount of working capital a business holds directly affects both these aspects.


1. Effect on Liquidity:
Liquidity refers to the ability of a firm to meet its short-term obligations as they become due. A larger investment in current assets (higher working capital) leads to higher liquidity. If a company has a sufficient amount of cash, marketable securities, and inventory, it is in a better position to pay its creditors on time. A low level of working capital impairs a firm's liquidity and can lead to insolvency.


2. Effect on Profitability:
Profitability is the ability of a business to earn a profit. Current assets are generally less profitable than fixed assets. For example, cash held in a current account earns very little or no interest. Therefore, a larger investment in current assets (higher working capital and liquidity) generally leads to lower overall profitability for the firm.

Thus, there is a conflict. A high level of working capital ensures high liquidity but reduces profitability. A low level of working capital increases profitability but compromises liquidity. A financial manager must strike a balance between the two.

Question 7. Aval Ltd. is engaged in the business of export of canvas goods and bags. In the past, the performance of the company had been upto the expectations. In line with the latest demand in the market, the company decided to venture into leather goods for which it required specialised machinery. For this, the Finance Manager Prabhu prepared a financial blueprint of the organisation’s future operations to estimate the amount of funds required and the timings with the objective to ensure that enough funds are available at right time. He also collected the relevant data about the profit estimates in the coming years. By doing this, he wanted to be sure about the availability of funds from the internal sources of the business. For the remaining funds, he is trying to find out alternative sources from outside.

a. Identify the financial concept discussed in the above paragraph. Also, state the objectives to be achieved by the use of financial concept so identified. ( Financial Planning).

b. ‘There is no restriction on payment of dividend by a company’. Comment. ( Legal & Contractual Constraints)

Answer:

a. Financial Concept and its Objectives:

The financial concept discussed in the paragraph is Financial Planning.

Prabhu is preparing a "financial blueprint" to estimate future fund requirements and their timings, which is the essence of financial planning.

The objectives of financial planning highlighted in the case are:

  1. To ensure availability of funds whenever required: The plan aims to "estimate the amount of funds required and the timings... to ensure that enough funds are available at right time."
  2. To identify the sources of funds: Prabhu is assessing the availability of internal funds and exploring alternative external sources.

b. Comment on 'There is no restriction on payment of dividend by a company':

The statement is incorrect.

A company's ability to pay dividends is subject to several restrictions:

  1. Legal Constraints: The Companies Act, 2013, lays down certain provisions regarding the declaration and payment of dividends. For instance, dividends must be paid out of current or past profits, and a company must provide for depreciation before declaring dividends.
  2. Contractual Constraints: When a company takes a loan, the lender may impose certain restrictions on the payment of dividends in the future. The company must adhere to these contractual obligations.

Therefore, a company is not completely free to pay dividends as it wishes; it must operate within the legal and contractual constraints.

Long Answer Type

Question 1. What is working capital? Discuss five important determinants of working capital requirement?

Answer:

Working capital refers to the capital of a business which is used in its day-to-day trading operations. It is the excess of current assets over current liabilities ($ \text{Net Working Capital} = \text{Current Assets} - \text{Current Liabilities} $). It is the portion of a firm's capital that is required to finance short-term assets like cash, inventory, and accounts receivable.


The requirement of working capital for a firm is determined by several factors. Five important determinants are:

1. Nature of Business: The basic nature of the business is a primary determinant. A trading organisation, which has to maintain a large stock of goods, will require more working capital than a manufacturing company. Similarly, a service industry (like a transport company) which has no inventory and mostly cash sales, will require less working capital.

2. Scale of Operations: The size of the business directly affects its working capital needs. A large-scale organisation will need to maintain more inventory and debtors and will thus require more working capital compared to a small-scale organisation.

3. Business Cycle: The working capital requirement is influenced by the different phases of the business cycle. During a boom period, sales and production are likely to be higher, requiring a larger investment in inventory and debtors. Conversely, during a period of depression or recession, the requirement for working capital will be lower.

4. Production Cycle: The production cycle is the time span between the receipt of raw materials and their conversion into finished goods. A longer production cycle means that funds will be tied up in raw materials and work-in-progress for a longer period, thus requiring more working capital. A shorter production cycle will require less working capital.

5. Credit Policy: The credit policy of a firm has two aspects:

  • Credit Allowed (to customers): A firm that follows a liberal credit policy and allows a long credit period to its customers will have a large amount of funds tied up in debtors, thus requiring more working capital.
  • Credit Availed (from suppliers): If a firm can get liberal credit terms from its suppliers, it can manage its operations with less working capital, as it can pay its suppliers after receiving cash from its customers.

Question 2. “Capital structure decision is essentially optimisation of risk-return relationship.” Comment.

Answer:

The statement "Capital structure decision is essentially optimisation of risk-return relationship" is absolutely correct. The choice of the proportion of debt and equity in a company's capital structure involves a fundamental trade-off between the potential return to the shareholders and the financial risk borne by the company.


The Return Aspect:

The use of debt (borrowed funds) in the capital structure has the potential to increase the return to the equity shareholders. This is because debt is a cheaper source of finance than equity. The interest paid on debt is a tax-deductible expense, which lowers the tax burden. If the company's Return on Investment (ROI) is higher than the interest rate on debt, the surplus earnings are magnified and go to the equity shareholders, increasing their Earnings Per Share (EPS). This phenomenon is known as 'Trading on Equity' or favourable financial leverage.


The Risk Aspect:

However, the use of debt also increases the financial risk for the company. This risk has two components:

1. Risk of Cash Insolvency: Debt involves a fixed commitment to pay interest and repay the principal amount, regardless of the company's earnings. If the company's earnings fall, it may default on these payments, which can lead to bankruptcy.

2. Increased Volatility of EPS: While debt can magnify positive returns, it also magnifies losses. The presence of fixed financial charges makes the EPS more volatile and sensitive to changes in the company's operating profit (EBIT).


Optimisation:

The capital structure decision, therefore, is about finding the optimal point where the benefits of using cheaper debt (higher return) are perfectly balanced by the costs of increased financial risk.

  • Too little debt may mean the company is not taking advantage of cheaper funds to increase shareholder returns.
  • Too much debt may increase the financial risk to an unacceptable level, which can depress the market value of the company's shares.
Thus, the goal of the finance manager is to design a capital structure that maximizes the market price of the equity share by achieving the optimal balance between risk and return.

Question 3. “A capital budgeting decision is capable of changing the financial fortunes of a business.” Do you agree? Give reasons for your answer?

Answer:

Yes, I completely agree with the statement that "A capital budgeting decision is capable of changing the financial fortunes of a business."

A capital budgeting decision, also known as an investment decision, is the decision to invest funds in long-term assets like land, buildings, machinery, or new projects. These decisions are of paramount importance and must be taken with utmost care because they affect the business's earnings, growth, and risk profile for a very long time.


The reasons why these decisions are so crucial are as follows:

1. Large Amount of Funds Involved: Capital budgeting decisions typically involve a very large outlay of funds. A wrong decision can result in a huge financial loss from which the company may never recover. A good decision can lead to substantial profits for years to come.

2. Long-term Growth and Effects: These decisions affect the long-term growth and profitability of the company. The future prospects of a business depend on the quality of the investment decisions it makes today. For example, investing in a new, efficient plant can give the company a competitive edge for the next decade.

3. Irreversibility of Decision: Capital budgeting decisions are largely irreversible. Once a firm has invested a huge amount in a fixed asset, it is very difficult and costly to reverse the decision. A wrong decision can become a long-term burden for the company.

4. High Degree of Risk: These decisions involve a high degree of risk because they are based on estimates of future returns, which are uncertain. A project's success depends on many factors in the business environment that are difficult to predict.

5. Impact on Competitive Strength: A timely and correct capital budgeting decision can significantly enhance a firm's competitive strength. For example, a decision to invest in the latest technology can improve product quality and reduce costs, giving the firm a major advantage over its rivals.

Therefore, a single, sound capital budgeting decision can propel a company to great heights, while a single poor decision can cripple its financial health and even lead to its closure.

Question 4. Explain the factors affecting dividend decision?

Answer:

The dividend decision involves deciding how much of the profit earned by the company should be distributed to the shareholders as a dividend and how much should be retained in the business for future investment (retained earnings). This decision is influenced by a number of factors:


1. Amount of Earnings: Dividends are paid out of current and past profits. The higher the earnings of a company, the higher the dividend it can declare.

2. Stability of Earnings: A company with stable and regular earnings is in a better position to declare higher dividends. A company with unstable earnings is likely to follow a more conservative dividend policy and pay a lower dividend.

3. Stability of Dividends: Companies generally follow a policy of dividend stabilisation. They prefer to maintain a stable dividend per share rather than increasing it in good years and cutting it in bad years, as investors prefer a regular and stable dividend income.

4. Growth Opportunities: A company with good growth opportunities will need more funds for investment. Such companies tend to retain a larger portion of their earnings and declare a lower dividend.

5. Cash Flow Position: The payment of dividends involves an outflow of cash. A company may be profitable but may not have enough cash to pay dividends. A good cash flow position is essential for a company to declare a liberal dividend.

6. Shareholder Preference: The dividend policy is also influenced by the preferences of the shareholders. If the shareholders of a company are generally retired persons who desire a regular income, the company may declare a higher dividend. If the shareholders are young and willing to take risks, they may prefer the company to retain the earnings and invest in growth.

7. Taxation Policy: The dividend policy is influenced by the tax treatment of dividends and capital gains. If the tax on dividends is higher than the tax on capital gains, shareholders may prefer the company to retain the earnings, which will lead to an increase in the share price (capital gain).

8. Access to Capital Markets: A large and reputed company with easy access to the capital market can afford to pay a higher dividend, as it can easily raise funds for its investment needs from external sources.

9. Legal and Contractual Constraints: The Companies Act lays down certain provisions regarding the payment of dividends. Also, loan agreements may contain restrictive clauses that limit a company's ability to declare dividends.

Question 5. Explain the term ‘Trading on Equity’? Why, when and how it can be used by company.

Answer:

Meaning of 'Trading on Equity'

Trading on Equity, also known as Financial Leverage, refers to the practice of using borrowed funds (debt) in the capital structure of a company with the objective of increasing the return to the equity shareholders. The term 'equity' here refers to the owner's funds.


Why it can be used:

The primary reason to use this strategy is to magnify the Earnings Per Share (EPS) of the equity shareholders. Debt is a cheaper source of finance than equity, and the interest paid on debt is a tax-deductible expense. When a company earns a return on its investments that is higher than the interest rate it pays on its debt, the surplus profit belongs to the equity shareholders, thereby boosting their returns.


When it can be used:

A company can successfully use trading on equity only when its Return on Investment (ROI) is greater than the rate of interest on the borrowed funds (Cost of Debt). If the ROI is less than the cost of debt, the strategy will backfire, and the EPS will decrease. This is known as unfavourable financial leverage.

It is also suitable for companies with stable and predictable earnings, as they can comfortably meet their fixed interest obligations.


How it can be used:

A company uses this strategy by including a significant proportion of debt (like debentures, bonds, or loans) and preference shares in its total capital structure, along with equity share capital. By financing its assets with a mix of debt and equity, the company leverages the fixed-cost funds to amplify the returns for its equity shareholders.

Example:
Suppose a company has a total capital of $\textsf{₹ } 10$ lakh and earns a profit (EBIT) of $\textsf{₹ } 2$ lakh (ROI = 20%). If it uses only equity, the return for shareholders is 20%. But if it uses $\textsf{₹ } 5$ lakh of equity and $\textsf{₹ } 5$ lakh of debt at 10% interest, the calculation is:
Profit (EBIT) = $\textsf{₹ } 2,00,000$
Less: Interest (10% on 5 lakh) = $\textsf{₹ } 50,000$
Profit for shareholders = $\textsf{₹ } 1,50,000$
The return on equity is now $\frac{1,50,000}{5,00,000} \times 100 = 30\%$. The EPS has been magnified from 20% to 30% through the use of debt.

Question 6. ‘S’ Limited is manufacturing steel at its plant in India. It is enjoying a buoyant demand for its products as economic growth is about 7–8 per cent and the demand for steel is growing. It is planning to set up a new steel plant to cash on the increased demand. It is estimated that it will require about `5000 crores to set up and about `500 crores of working capital to start the new plant.

a. Describe the role and objectives of financial management for this company.

b. Explain the importance of having a financial plan for this company. Give an imaginary plan to support your answer.

c. What are the factors which will affect the capital structure of this company?

d. Keeping in mind that it is a highly capital-intensive sector, what factors will affect the fixed and working capital. Give reasons in support of your answer.

Answer:

a. Role and Objectives of Financial Management:

For 'S' Limited, the role of financial management will be crucial in its expansion project. The key roles will be:

  • To estimate the total financial requirement of $\textsf{₹ } 5500$ crores.
  • To decide the sources from which this massive amount of funds will be raised.
  • To manage the investment of these funds in the new plant efficiently.
  • To ensure the company maintains adequate liquidity during and after the expansion.

The primary objective of financial management will be to make financial decisions that maximise the wealth of the equity shareholders. This means the new plant should be financed and operated in a way that it increases the market price of the company's shares.


b. Importance of a Financial Plan and an Imaginary Plan:

Importance: Financial planning is of immense importance for this project because:

  • It will help the company to successfully manage the massive fund requirement of $\textsf{₹ } 5500$ crores.
  • It helps in coordinating the functions of various departments and links the investment and financing decisions.
  • It helps in avoiding business shocks and surprises by anticipating future financial needs.
  • It provides a framework for financial control and helps in evaluating actual performance.

Imaginary Financial Plan for Raising $\textsf{₹ } 5500$ Crores:

Source of Finance Amount (in Crores) Justification
Equity Share Capital (FPO) $\textsf{₹ } 2000$ To build a strong equity base for such a large project and support future borrowing.
Retained Earnings $\textsf{₹ } 500$ Using internal profits as it's the cheapest source of finance.
Debentures (10%) $\textsf{₹ } 1500$ To take advantage of cheaper debt and tax savings on interest.
Term Loan from Financial Institutions $\textsf{₹ } 1500$ To get long-term funds and expert financial advice from institutions.
Total $\textsf{₹ } 5500$

c. Factors Affecting the Capital Structure:

  • Cash Flow Position: Since the demand is buoyant, the company can expect strong and stable cash flows once the plant is operational, which will support the use of a higher proportion of debt.
  • Cost of Debt: As an established and growing company, 'S' Limited can likely raise debt at a low rate of interest, making it an attractive source of finance.
  • Risk Consideration: The steel sector has high business risk due to its cyclical nature. Therefore, the company must be careful not to take on excessive debt, which would increase its financial risk to a dangerous level.
  • Control: Issuing new equity shares worth $\textsf{₹ } 2000$ crores will dilute the control of the existing shareholders. This might push the management to prefer debt over equity.
  • Stock Market Conditions: The ability to raise a large sum through equity will depend on the condition of the stock market. A bullish market would be favourable for an equity issue.

d. Factors Affecting Fixed and Working Capital:

Factors Affecting Fixed Capital ($\textsf{₹ } 5000$ crores):

  • Nature of Business: Steel manufacturing is a highly capital-intensive industry. Reason: It requires massive investments in land, buildings, and heavy machinery like blast furnaces and rolling mills.
  • Scale of Operations: The company is setting up a new plant to meet growing demand, indicating a large scale of operations. Reason: Large-scale production is necessary to achieve economies of scale in the steel industry, which requires a higher investment in fixed assets.
  • Choice of Technology: To be competitive, the company will have to invest in modern, capital-intensive technology. Reason: Advanced technology improves efficiency and product quality but requires a huge investment in fixed assets.

Factors Affecting Working Capital ($\textsf{₹ } 500$ crores):

  • Production Cycle: The process of converting raw materials like iron ore into finished steel is very long. Reason: A long production cycle means that funds remain tied up in raw materials and work-in-progress for an extended period, requiring a higher amount of working capital.
  • Scale of Operations: A large steel plant requires a huge stock of raw materials to ensure continuous production and a large stock of finished goods to meet customer orders. Reason: Higher levels of inventory directly increase the working capital requirement.
  • Credit Allowed: 'S' Limited will be selling steel to large industrial buyers who are likely to demand a credit period. Reason: Granting credit to customers creates debtors (accounts receivable), which represents funds blocked in sales, thus increasing the need for working capital.